fbpix

In short: On 20 October 2026 the Johannesburg High Court refused to give residential estates a blanket green light to charge estate agents “accreditation” fees before they may market or sell homes in the estate. The ruling does not ban every fee, and each case will turn on its own facts. It does, however, carry a clear warning for agents who pay these fees, and good news for sellers who want to choose their own agent.

“Your home, your choice of agent.”

The fight in a nutshell

For years many estates have required agents to pay a fee, often annually, before they may list, show or sell property inside the estate. The Residential Communities Council (RCC), which represents 181 private estates, and the Association of Residential Communities asked the High Court to declare that these fees are not an undesirable business practice under Regulation 35 of the Property Practitioners Regulations, read with section 63 of the Property Practitioners Act (PPA).

The estates argued that the PPA regulates agents, not estates, so the regulator has no say over what homeowners’ associations (HOAs) and bodies corporate charge. They say the fee pays for training on estate rules, security on show days, website advertising and administration.

The Property Practitioners Regulatory Authority (PPRA) opposed the application, and REBOSA filed an affidavit supporting the PPRA. According to the court papers, fees range from about R5,000 to R50,000 a year, and the PPRA’s CEO has said that some gated estates charge as much as R40,000 to R80,000. The PPRA gave the court two examples involving RCC members. One estate refused to issue levy clearance figures on sales by agents who had not paid its R5,000 fee. Another charged a private seller a R10,000 “penalty” for not using an accredited agent.

What the court decided

Acting Judge NS Krüger dismissed the application with costs. The RCC had not proved its case. Fees differ from estate to estate, and no member estate filed its own supporting affidavit. Whether a particular HOA or body corporate falls under the PPA depends on its founding documents and what it actually does.

The court also took a hard look at the effect of these fees. Depending on the facts, they may limit buyers’ and sellers’ choice of agent, push up costs and put another hurdle in front of new and emerging agents. That is exactly the harm the property regulations are meant to prevent.

What the court did not decide

The headlines don’t tell the whole story. The court did not declare all accreditation fees unlawful, and it did not find that HOAs are property practitioners. It simply refused to give every estate in the country blanket protection. Louis Kruger of Kruger Attorneys and Conveyancers says the ruling is “narrower than the headlines may suggest”.

In practice each arrangement will be judged on its own facts: what the fee is, what it buys, and how payment is demanded. The PPRA says it can now deal with complaints case by case.

The sting in the tail: the agent who pays

This is the part every agent needs to read twice. Regulation 35 prohibits the arrangement itself, so an agent who pays for preferential access to an estate is a party to it. Even if the PPRA can’t reach the estate, it can certainly reach the agent. Under section 62(3) of the PPA, an agent found to have taken part in an undesirable practice faces a fine, a public reprimand or the withdrawal of their Fidelity Fund certificate. Without a valid FFC you can’t trade, and you can’t legally earn commission.

A fee labelled “voluntary” is not automatically safe either.

One more thing to watch: in November 2025 the PPRA put enforcement of Regulation 35 on hold until there was a final court order. The RCC may still apply for leave to appeal, and it isn’t yet clear whether that hold is still in place. Don’t read the uncertainty as a green light.

What it means for sellers

It’s your property, and you choose who markets it. The CSOS Practice Directive of 2025 already treats a scheme rule that allows only certain agents to sell or let units as undesirable. If your estate refuses clearance figures, charges you a penalty or blocks your agent because they are not “accredited”, put your complaint in writing and get advice. That is precisely the kind of conduct the PPRA put before the court.

Estates may still enforce reasonable security and conduct rules, such as signing in, escorting buyers and keeping to show-day times. Your agent should respect those.

A quick checklist for agents

  • Don’t sign accreditation agreements or pay access fees without understanding exactly what you are paying for and whether access depends on it.
  • Ask for it in writing. If an estate blocks you or your seller over a fee, keep the correspondence and report it to the PPRA.
  • Tell your seller. They have a right to know if the estate is limiting their choice of agent.
  • Follow the estate’s security and conduct rules. The fee is the issue, not the rules.

Bottom line

The court refused to give estates blanket protection, and the PPRA now has room to act case by case. For sellers, that means more freedom to choose an agent. For agents, the message is uncomfortable but simple: paying could cost you your Fidelity Fund certificate. If in doubt, don’t pay, and take advice from a property attorney or the PPRA.

How we handle it at PropertyTime: As the principal, PropertyTime does not allow its agents to pay estate accreditation, access or marketing fees. If an estate demands one of these fees, our agents are asked not to list in that estate rather than pay it. The one exception is a genuine security check fee. Where an estate charges for security vetting of agents who enter it, sometimes once a year, our policy allows the agent to pay it. Anything beyond that would expose our agents, and PropertyTime as the principal, to sanctions and fines from the PPRA, and that is a risk we will not take. If you are selling in an estate, you can list with a PropertyTime agent knowing they are working within the law.


With acknowledgement to Property Professional, “Estate fees: the court has spoken, but agents are not off the hook” (26 October 2026), including comments by Louis Kruger, MD of Kruger Attorneys and Conveyancers Inc, and to STBB’s real estate alert on Residential Communities Council and Others v Minister of Human Settlements (10 November 2026).

Sources: Property Professional (26 October 2026); STBB (10 November 2026); IOL (26 and 27 October 2026); The Citizen; Moneyweb; Real Estate Investor (REI); Property Practitioners Act 22 of 2019 and Regulations; CSOS Consolidated Practice Directive 1 of 2025.

Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and is not legal, financial or other professional advice. PropertyTime and Pierre Rousseau take care to make sure the information is accurate at the time of publication, but laws, regulations and court decisions change, and errors or omissions can occur. Parts of the research for this article were AI-assisted and reviewed before publication. No responsibility is accepted for any loss or damage arising from reliance on this content. Where we draw on the work of attorneys, conveyancers, publications or other sources, they are acknowledged above. The views expressed here are not necessarily theirs, and they are not responsible for how their work has been interpreted or applied in this article. Always get advice from a qualified professional about your own circumstances.